Three AI pitches a week is normal now. An email, a LinkedIn message, a cold call about an AI receptionist. They all sound confident and they all sound similar, and you can’t verify a word of it from where you’re sitting.
One test does most of the work. A real seller will show you the thing working on your own business before you pay, and will say nothing about what you’ll earn. A scam does the reverse. It promises the earnings and puts off the product.
Start with one question: am I buying a tool, or an income?
Two different pitches arrive in your inbox, and they need different treatment.
One is software or a service. Someone will set up AI to answer your phone, draft your quotes, or sort your email. The promise is about what the software does.
The other is a business. Buy a licence, resell this AI to other businesses, here are some leads to start you off. The promise is about what you’ll make.
The moment a pitch starts describing your future income, stop treating it as software. You’re being sold a financial product by someone with no obligation to be right. Earnings claims are also what regulators prosecute, which tells you how often they turn out to be true.
What one of these looked like from the inside
In August 2025 the FTC sued a company called Air AI and three of its operators in federal court in Arizona. Everything in this section is what the FTC alleges in its complaint. None of it has been proved at trial.
The complaint says that since at least February 2023 the defendants took consumers for roughly $19 million. There were two products. An “Air AI Access Card” bundled coaching with AI business software and sold for $15,000 to $30,000. A licence to resell the company’s conversational AI sold for $25,000 to $100,000. The buyers, per the complaint, were mostly people starting coaching businesses and owners who wanted AI in a business they already ran. The FTC says they lost as much as $100,000 and were “frequently left in debt” (complaint, ¶10).
The pitch, quoted in the complaint, promised an AI that could “have full on 10-40 minute long phone conversations that sound like a REAL human”. It had “[z]ero ramp up time” and “requires zero management”. On earnings it claimed “a recent License holder generated $450,000 in revenue in their first thirty days”. The FTC’s assessment of all of it runs to four words: “Defendants’ claims are fantasy.”
Here is what the complaint says buyers got. For some, the conversational AI was never available at all. When it was, it was “often not able to perform basic functions like placing outbound calls to businesses, scheduling appointments, taking down email addresses, or responding accurately to questions”. And it was not a done-for-you product. Making it work “requires a substantial time commitment where consumers must pre-script answers for every potential question”.
A man who had bought a licence tried to demo the AI to a building company. The complaint describes how that went:
After troubleshooting and working around numerous software flaws, including the AI agent reading portions of the script not intended to be said aloud, hanging up on consumers moments after they picked up the phone, and struggling to accurately transcribe even basic consumer information, the License-holding consumer found that the AI test agent would not stick to the script, and simply made-up answers when it was asked questions for which he had not supplied responses. He determined that he could not possibly present the product to the intended buyer because it would not work as advertised.
He ran exactly the right test, after he had paid. Running it first costs nothing.
Make them run your task in front of you
A recorded call, a case study, and a polished sales video all prove nothing. Ask for your task, your actual phone script, the messy question your customers really ask, in front of you, before money moves.
Then ask the follow-up that the passage above makes obvious. What does it do when it doesn’t know the answer? A real seller has a ready answer: it takes a message, escalates to a person, or says it doesn’t know. A seller who tells you the situation won’t come up has just told you they haven’t tested it. We wrote more about that failure in how do I know the AI isn’t making it up.
Treat “zero setup” and “zero management” as warnings rather than features. Somebody has to write the answers, teach it your prices, and update it when they change. Ask who does that, how long it takes, and what it costs you when your prices change in March.
The price should not move when you say no
The complaint alleges the defendants “appear to set the price depending on a consumers’ ability to pay, extracting as much money from each individual consumer as possible”. It also alleges that paying more got you nothing extra. There were no tiers. Same product, different price, depending on what you could be talked into.
So say the price is too high and watch what happens. If the number moves, you’re in a negotiation.
Don’t let the seller arrange your financing either. The FTC alleges this company brokered loans through its own platform at interest rates up to 24.99%. It also alleges buyers were talked into opening new credit cards to cover the cost. A seller whose business model needs you to borrow has an interest in your optimism, not your result.
A guarantee is only worth what the company behind it can pay
Air AI’s contract, per the complaint, carried a clause headed “THE AIR AI GUARANTEE & EXPECTATIONS”. It promised that within six months you would have made back double what you paid, and that if you hadn’t, you could cancel and get a full refund. The FTC alleges the sellers brought this clause up exactly when buyers hesitated about the cost, which left people believing the purchase was “essentially ‘risk free’”.
The FTC also alleges the company “very rarely honor[ed]” it, strung people along for months, and cut some buyers off from the service while their refund request sat open.
The complaint then quotes an August 2024 email from one of the owners to several customers:
[O]ur company has come into some intense financial hardship. … We as owners have put 100% of our personal capital into keeping things afloat. We have spent 100% of our cash, maxed out our credit, and even given up our apartment to cut back. … We are completely out of cash at this moment.
One buyer, quoted in the complaint, worked out what that meant. He grew “concerned that they would just be raising money from other people like me to pay out my refund.”
Then look at how it ended. In March 2026 the FTC announced a settlement it had filed with the court. Under the proposed order, Air AI and its operators would be banned from selling or marketing any business opportunity, and from making earnings claims without substantiation. It carries a monetary judgment of $18 million, and that judgment is largely suspended because they can’t pay it. The amount the operators would actually hand over for consumer relief is $50,000 (FTC, March 2026). An order like that only carries the force of law once a judge signs it, and as of November 2026 the FTC’s case page still lists the case as pending.
So read a guarantee as a credit question. Ask who honours the refund if the company folds next quarter. Ask how many refunds they paid in the last twelve months, and for how much. A promise is worth what the balance sheet behind it is worth.
If they talk about what you’ll earn, you have rights. Use them.
If someone is selling you a business rather than a tool, US law may class it as a “business opportunity” under the FTC’s Business Opportunity Rule. Broadly, that’s when a seller recruits you into a new business, you have to pay to get in, and they tell you they will provide customers or outlets for what you’ll be selling. If it is one, the seller owes you documents before you pay, by law. You don’t have to ask.
- A one-page disclosure document, in the form the Rule prescribes, given to you at least seven days before you sign anything or pay anything. It has to cover who they are, any legal actions involving misrepresentation or fraud in the past ten years, their cancellation and refund policy, earnings, and references.
- References means a real list. Contact details for at least ten people who have bought from them. If more than ten have, it has to be the ten living closest to you. That detail exists so the seller can’t hand you one friendly name.
- If they make any earnings claim at all, a separate document headed “EARNINGS CLAIM STATEMENT REQUIRED BY LAW”. It has to give the specifics of the claim, the dates those earnings were achieved, and the number and percentage of their buyers who got at least that result.
That last one is the best question you can ask anyone selling you an income. You told me people make thirty thousand a month. Show me the earnings claim statement with the percentage of your buyers who did.
The FTC’s advice about the silence that follows is blunt. “If a seller doesn’t give you the information you know they have to provide, walk away.” And if what you’re being told differs from what’s written down, or from what another buyer tells you, “step on the brake” (FTC, Bogus Business Opportunities).
If it’s just software or a service, none of that applies. No new business, no promised customers, no disclosure rights. Which is why, in the ordinary case, the test has to be the demo on your own work.
The checks that cost nothing
Ten minutes, before any money moves.
- Search the company name with “complaint” and with “scam”.
- Read the review sites, and read the one-star reviews rather than the average.
- Check the Better Business Bureau and your state attorney general.
- Search the FTC’s own case list for the company name.
- Find a customer they didn’t pick for you. The FTC warns that promoters have been known to name “insiders” who give glowing but bogus recommendations.
In this case those searches would have turned something up. The complaint notes that by the time the FTC filed, Trustpilot carried 78 one-star reviews of the company against three positive ones. It also notes that four private plaintiffs sued during 2024. The defendants defaulted in at least three of those suits and kept selling.
Those reviews are worth reading for the size of the loss. It’s bigger than a wasted subscription. One reviewer wrote that they had taken out a loan to pay for it and that the platform was “still riddled with bugs”. Another wrote that they had waited nine months for a promised refund, and got a repayment schedule only after complaining to their state attorney general. These are buyers’ own accounts rather than findings of fact, and the FTC’s complaint points at the same review page.
Name the pressure out loud
The complaint describes a sales process built to stop you doing any of the above. Limited licences, so delay means missing out. A mandatory video before the “closing call” that the FTC describes as an extended sales pitch. Being told within minutes of your first call that you’re a “perfect” candidate. Buyers who came in wanting AI for their own business getting upsold the chance to resell it instead.
One rule covers all of them. An offer that expires before you can check it is telling you not to check it. A real price will still be there on Monday.
And if the conversation drifts away from the problem you called about, notice it. You wanted your phone answered. If you’re now looking at slides about revenue share, this stopped being about you.
The same template, over and over
Air AI is not an outlier. In September 2024 the FTC announced action against five separate operations over deceptive AI claims. Then-Chair Lina Khan’s line is the one to remember: “there is no AI exemption from the laws on the books.” In March 2025 the FTC went after another operation, alleging it had cost consumers at least $14 million selling AI-powered online stores. Buyers paid management fees starting at $45,000. Amazon then blocked, suspended or terminated about 95% of the stores.
The template is older than AI. Business opportunity fraud has been around for a century. AI is just the current reason the earnings claim is supposed to be believable this time.
Most people selling AI services are selling a service. Someone configuring tools to do a specific job in your business is doing ordinary work for ordinary money. These cases are about the layer that sits on top of that. Coaching and licences that sell the dream of running such a business, to people who then have no customers. Air AI sold both at once.
What an honest offer looks like
This is our opinion, not a legal standard. It’s also what we think you should hold any seller to, including us.
- One specific task, named, with an honest estimate of what it costs you in time today
- A demonstration on your own material before any money changes hands
- A plain statement of what the thing cannot do, and what happens when it fails
- A price you could have read off a page
- A clear answer to “what do I own if we stop working together?”
- No number attached to your future revenue
Nobody can tell you what AI will earn you. Anyone who does has told you everything you need to know about them. For the same reason, nobody can sell you a ranking in ChatGPT, which we wrote about separately.
The test: can they show it working on your own task today, and have they said anything about what you’ll earn? If a seller can’t do the first, or won’t stop doing the second, keep your money.